Lee, I usually agree with you, but on this one I'm not so sure. I teach college level English, and grammar is a major concern for me. So many students have no idea about proper comma usage, what a semicolon is, differences in words like lie/lay, the purpose of a prepositional phrase, how to create a proper complex sentence, etc. Personally, I'd love to see a lot more grammar in high school. It doesn't have to be diagramming, but understanding the rules of the language are important. Passing the ACT/SAT is just one step. After that, communication is critical to success in almost every field. With the increase in technology, more and more of our communication is written rather than spoken, and it needs to be articulate and accurate to be well received. Just my two cents... April
I agree that communication and WRITTEN communication is the HUGE deal. In fact, that's what I hear colleges complain about the most, is the ability for students in English. They tell me that many public school kids come to college without the ability to read and write well - regardless of their grades in high school. I guess my point is that reading and writing well are critical, but that you don't need to do a separate study of grammar every year. After a certain point, it's more about practice and honing your writing skills.
PS. This is one of those times when I really hope I haven't made a grammatical or spelling error, LOL!!
I will agree with April. My children will have grammar for all of their school years, through high school. It is not just excellent preparation for life, but the college tests as well. Improper grammar annoys me to no end!!!! A yearly program helps them practice and strengthen skills.
We study grammar very seriously through junior high, so by the time they reach high school, so much is simply review. I have had an incredibly hard time finding an appropriate grammar book for high school that isn't just a rehash, poor at that, of what we've already mastered. Because of that, review is just what we do. My hs-er plunks away at the highlights for about 10 minutes a day most of the time as a refresher, and it must work bc she got an almost perfect score on the written SAT her first try. I guess my point is I can appreciate both sides. Grammar is vital as the underpinnings of our language, but if mastered in the early years, it shouldn't have to absorb much of your resources when high school rolls around.
Please correct any grammatical errors, my luck and it's full of them.
I'm just starting high school this year with my oldest (and with 6 children, I'll be doing it for a quite a while - 16 more years!! LOL) and I completely understand, Lee. I think I would really bog down my guys if we did formal grammar each year. My plan is to do grammar this year, maybe take a break from grammar and do lots of writing the next year and see where we need to go from there. I'm wondering though, when you say "focus on the grammar they need for the SAT and ACT", how do you know what is needed? Are there specific courses, etc. available? And, of course, what would you recommend?
Thanks so much, Lee!
I like using the "Real SAT" books. Here is an article about the SAT and ACT that will help: http://www.thehomescholar.com/sat-tests.php
If you regularly use words like field-tripping and work-shopping, this tip is for you! Bonnie writes about how her final sacrificial culmination of homeschooling was creating course descriptions that earned